July 20, 2006
Over on Rob’s blog, he talked about whether it was useful to create a trailer for a book. Would they generate sales? Would people even bother to view them? And, speaking of viewing, where in the hell would you put one so that people could see it? He mentioned a friend of his who was in the process of having hired actors and filming and editing — a true movie-like trailer version. That friend would be me. I’d mentioned what I was doing to him a while back, and then we talked about it in greater detail at ThrillerFest, but I hadn’t posted about it in detail until now.
I’m not surprised to see the somewhat unenthusiastic comments about whether or not a book trailer will be useful — it’s still a very new type of marketing tool. Many “book trailers” which have been done thus far (from flash to live action videos) have been cheesy or downright dreadful, which, of course, has the opposite affect of that desired by the writer: to attract the viewer to the book. But before we chuck it out as a possibility, let’s look at something for a minute here: you’re reading a blog. Seven or eight years ago, when I first started journaling online, there were a few hundred journals, and many of us knew each other. I thought I was a late-comer to the party. If you had told me back then that by 2006, more than 30 million people would have blogs (online journals), I would have thought you’d been sniffing the glue a little too much. A few years before that, the notion that people would publish essays on something called the “internet” and that other people would go read them… that people would form a lot of “boards” on various topics, that people would meet and become friends… marriages would happen… online shopping… “channels” for media (YouTube.com), etc. Most authors didn’t have webpages. Or blogs. And now those are considered essential to marketing one’s own book, to connecting with the readers, and to creating a “brand.” No one really thought all of that would happen in that short a span of time. (MySpace.com anyone?) We have Ipods which hold a phenomenal amount of songs and videos, where a person can subscribe now to videos. There’s satellite TV, satellite phones, satellite internet. There are TVs available on the refrigerator or the microwave. Media has changed our world. We, as writers, are benefiting from it via blogs and internet networking / marketing.
So, what’s next? And why?
I’m cribbing one of my comments posted over on Allison’s post for the Murder She Writes blog:
There has been a lot of talk in the past on various blogs about how readership is shrinking and how difficult it is to get a younger generation to pick up a book instead of watching TV or movie or playing a video game. I think a large part of the problem is that many of these kids either had terrible experiences with boring reading selections in high school (or in some cases, terrible teachers who made good books a dull, mind-numbing experience). When you look at an entire generation who has grown up with multi-media as the norm, then getting them to sit down and read a book is going to be difficult because they don’t really know the world of books and the adventures they could experience there. I’ve been pretty surprised at just how many people don’t really understand what “fiction” is — and didn’t ever really think about the fact that their favorite movie — or TV show — or game — was born from a writer.
So, how do we reach that sort of audience and bring them to reading? Especially if they’re not young adults and / or have been lured in by the Harry Potter phenom? I think one way to at least increase curiosity is the book trailer, if it’s done really well.
My personal feeling is that when an occasional reader ponders the thought of a bookstore, they are intimidated by the sheer volume of the choices. They don’t know the author’s names, they don’t really know the genre, and they think of it as the essay-torture they endured during high school. The only books which tend to break through this confusion / resistance are the best-sellers. Some people, for example, read the Da Vinci Code simply because they had heard about it and heard it was a thriller / page turner and became curious. This type of reader would probably read more, if they knew what to look for or who… if they had an inkling before buying the book as to the tone / hook. How is a debut author, or a mid-list author, then, to break through the clutter and entice them? You’re unlikely to get the occasional readers to visit a blog or read an excerpt, but they do tend to look at video more frequently.
I’m in the process of doing final edits for mine. It won’t go up on an official site, though, until much closer to the book is available for sale (May, ‘07), because there’s no point in having it up if people can’t seek it out. Do I think it’ll increase sales? I have no clue, no real expectations. But if I can make people chuckle (Bobbie Faye’s Very (very very very) Bad Day is a comedic caper), then maybe they’ll remember it when they’re passing through a Target or, egads, an actual book store. (grin) And just breaking through to some level of recognition should help. (Unless they hate the trailer. Yikes.)
I don’t know how well my video will do. Like I said there, I’ll have a very short version and the longer (funnier) version, and I hope they are well received. I do know that just doing a blog isn’t working for me — I keep thinking of writing topics, only to see others already covering them well enough. I’ve got a crazy idea for a webpage that Rob and a few of my fellow Killer Year classmates liked which I will put up. Ultimately, the book has to stand as a book — there can be no doubt about that. But getting people to be aware of it, maybe attracting them to it through other media — who knows? What seems like a crazy thing to do today may just be the standard of tomorrow. With professional cameras and editing software available, it’s possible. I, personally, would rather look at the potential, at the positive, and aim for that. I know a lot of typical readers won’t bother with the videos — they’ll come to the book in a more traditional way and that’s great! I’d love all of those readers. But I think videos may just open a few other doors to potential readers who wouldn’t normally have thought of picking up the book, and if we can take back some of the audience the publishing industry has lost… it’s a good thing. I’d like to experiment, see what works and run with it.
You just never know.
What do you think of book trailers? Or, perhaps more importantly, what do you think are the most useful innovations for writers now?
18 Responses to “the book trailer discussion…”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
July 20, 2006 at 11:41 pm
Hey, Toni. This is all getting a little incestuous… I haven’t yet made up my mind about trailers. I think if you can REALLY knock people’s socks off, then you might start a trend. But while I think some of the trailers I’ve seen are pretty good, none of them has really thrilled me (and I include my own attempts).
There are a couple outfits out there doing fullscale book trailers, but they just don’t do it for me personally.
I’ve seen a few that even remind me of really bad direct to video trailers.
But it’s a start. I remember when music videos were extremely cheesy. Now they’re like mini-movies.
July 21, 2006 at 5:52 am
Well, and YouTube has got to have a tremendous impact on this. You should check out what Jeff VanderMeer’s doing — of course, there’s a whole movie there, but he just stuck up the trailer for it on YouTube yesterday.
July 21, 2006 at 10:35 am
Really, Rob? When I read your entry, I thought you were thinking pretty negatively about trailers at all. I mean, I know you said you’d considered doing what Toni is doing, but you seemed to have already dismissed it for reasons you explained.
It’s like a lot of things. A few people will do it really well — most will do it really poorly. Then the publishers will see value in it and start doing it themselves, and any author-attempts will seem paltry in comparison.
I remember when the big deal was bookmarks, and writers were making their own to give at book signings and to send t o book stores to promote their books. Then somebody started doing 4-color and all the others looked cheap and lame. Then the publishers started doing them. Then the book stores started tossing them in the trash unless they were really special, because they were getting so many of them.
July 21, 2006 at 7:47 pm
what do you think are the most useful innovations for writers now?
I got all excited the day IBM invented those Selectrics that auto-corrected.
July 22, 2006 at 11:15 pm
I really like Allison Brennan’s book trailer. It intrigues me. I’m not sure a book trailer should do anything more, as long as it accomplishes your ultimate goal: get people to read your book.
And what better way than to intrigue them.
July 23, 2006 at 5:54 am
Oh you know me Toni, I buy everything “As Seen on TV.”
It’s a great idea. Imagine someone flicking through the channels, bored as hell with the tv and the trailer plays. That’s it, they need that book. I haven’t seen any of them yet, but what an exciting new concept. Surprised they haven’t been doing it for years.
Hell, if they can sell colon cleansers on there…
July 24, 2006 at 5:29 pm
I think your trailer is going to be unique and absolutely fabulous, Toni.
And you are right on the money about the younger generation . . . we need to nab them fast (i.e. covers, blurbs, first lines) but also get them to pick up the book in the first place. I’ve loved reading my entire life, but some teachers could make any book boring.
BTW, I had a teacher in HS who assigned THE PRINCESS BRIDE by William Goldman. Our entire final was on that book. One of the best classes, and best teachers, I ever had.
July 25, 2006 at 12:35 am
Thank you to everyone. Mindy, as always, you crack me up. I remember that moment, too, and was nearly in tears, I was so excited not to have to retype a whole page for a typo (that I’d tired to fix with that white out paper you used to have to put in exactly the right spot and type the letter over it. I never did manage to get that stuff lined up correctly.) Wow. I had forgotten all about that.
Pooks, thanks — I think you’re right. Many will be attempted, some will be good, others not, but I think it’s going to catch on. Already — in just what? a year? we’re seeing a proliferation of the trailers and companies who make them when that really didn’t exist much before.
Kitty, you crack me up.
We are so so so the same person.
Gwenda, I hadn’t seen that one - I will definitely check it out. And I do think YouTube will have a big impact on this, too.
Rob, I dunno. I like what you’re doing, so that’s one way to go, but I don’t think it works for what I write, which is comedy. Mine may not work — we’ll see. I did go pick up the edited copy to take with me to show friends at RWA just to see if it’s working, so I guess I’ll know for sure this week!
Elizabeth, totally agree — love Allison’s. In fact, she was a great inspiration for doing this. And agree with the need to intrigue.
Allison, you rock, (but you already know that). Thank you. I’ll be bringing it to show you, so you can say if it works.
July 26, 2006 at 10:49 am
I am a writer working on a novel. I am also completing my last year in an MFA writing program. One of the faculty in my institution just put a book out (her second) and has a website etc. like many authors do. Some of the older faculty members, who are also published writers, many with 5 and 10 books out, (some out of print, sadly) are disdainful of this–there is a certain snobbery attached to being part of the exclusive club called “literary fiction writers” and there is a certain behavior that is expected: tremendous humility and modesty ( much of it false–when you get to know these guys they are often egocentric divas) and a certain kind of shyness and soft spokenness. I am an empowered female in her 50’s and this sort of behavior is not me, doesn’t suit me and I don’t plan to fake it. The publishing industry is still largely dominated by men, even though there are thousands of wonderful female writers, the decision making is often done by men, and there is a prodigious amount of ageism. They like young girls who have talent–old girls who have talent have hell to pay to break in. What has this got to do with trailers? Well, coming from being a screenwriter originally and being part of the Independent Film world, (which I, in my own private brand of snobbery, disdain) I am happy to see anything that will promote reading and help writers sell books. If this means reaching people through visual medium, I am all for it. As you mentioned on your blog, alot of people these days are intimidated by bookstores and don’t even really know one genre from another. The literate portion of society has shrunk, or perhaps, it was never very big to begin with, but now with television, ipods, podcasts, dvd and film there are so many other choices for getting story that people don’t want to slow down and ingest the beauty of communicating with the mind of a writer and entering into another world through their own imagination. This is sad. Therefore, I am all for anything that will improve the situation. I must admit that my local Borders and Barnes and Noble are always packed with people, so I am convinced the public is hungry and even greedy for new thoughts and ideas and characters and stories–a book is still and always will be a viable place for the imagination to go. I, too, had a blog and found it discouraging because I never knew who was or was not reading and the vast amorphous “out there” was not terribly satisfying. I am sure, should I somehow land a publishing deal, that I will be more than happy to have a website and if my publisher suggests a trailer–you bet!
August 1, 2006 at 9:50 pm
Hiya Toni, long time no see, sorry for that.
Just a thought as to the differences between the generations.
My husband grew up in a house that didn’t have a tv till he was in high school (he missed all the holiday specials ~~ The Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown comes to mind) and his parents encouraged reading. Now as an adult he loves it, while his youngest brother couldn’t be bothered (we still think he used Clif Notes to get through Law School!) to read because he had basically grown up with the tv (6 years difference between the two). So I think it’s actual exposure to reading and now with technology being what it is…
Well you can see how slippery that slope is.
There’s a writer who I’d never heard of (Iris Johansen) and actually (believe it or not) had heard a radio ad for her book Ugly Duckling. It intrigued me (yes they will come if you intice and intrigue) and bought the book. At the time I didn’t know she had other books out and as time progressed bought each book and read them with a hunger. While I still haven’t read her romance novels (not my thang) I’ve read pretty much everything else she’s done. At the time I heard the radio ad, I’d never heard of that before…doing an ad on the radio and thought it was odd. But because of the ad I did do what was sought of me.
Since then I’ve not heard may books promoted this way (tragically) although I think it’s interesting, because now with satellite radio being what it is, you can reach an even broader audience.
So all this is to say, the trailer is a great idea, it would be intriguing (at least to me) and I’d definately check it out. Hitch is, where would it be played? Internet? TV? Movie theaters?
You know I’m gonna be there for a first edition regardless of what you choose to do, but I am interested as well to see this from your perspective and how it all comes together to be seen as the public would see it.
Big hugs to ya!
August 7, 2006 at 3:27 pm
Can’t read what you don’t know is out there. That, to me is the biggest problem facing books & reading. I was nearly a year late in finding out about a favorite author deciding to write 4 more books to “end” a two trilogy series. I never saw any advertising on the new books, I only happened to stumble across some obscure article mentioning it. Then I went to the authors web page to confirm. Authors web pages, book store displays - those are rather static. They don’t work if you don’t get to them. What’s needed is something that goes out and attracts readers - in places where the static displays aren’t. Maybe trailers will do that.
ps - I still owe you tater/snowball gun pictures. Going to have to wait for a little snow fall. Maybe a video on YouTube this winter?
August 8, 2006 at 1:19 am
BTW, I saw Toni’s trailer. With minor editing IT ROCKS!!! And her book is fabulous too . . . I’m almost done.
August 8, 2006 at 6:19 pm
Hee, I almost missed this. Thanks, Allison! The editing is almost done (actually, it may be done now, I have to check on the guys editing)… and I am really happy about it. Highly recommended: show a trailer to a bunch of people at a conference. You’ll get great comments and really helpful insight — fast. Plus, they know what you’re trying for, so they can tell you whether you’ve hit it or not.
(And don’t think I didn’t notice that last sentence. WOO!)(Thanks!)
August 8, 2006 at 6:49 pm
Hi Toni,
I never really thought of doing a trailer until I stumbled across Allison’s very simple and dramatic (and short!) trailer for The Prey. And did I say classy? It grabbed and inspired me to the point that I’m going to have one produced for my debut fiction thriller. If anyone out there has some samples they can point out that were particularly well made — I’d love to see them.
Gregg
http://www.greggolsen.com
October 25, 2006 at 11:53 am
I haven’t heard much about Shannon lately. What is she up to?
February 10, 2007 at 2:45 pm
There is now a page on Wikipedia dedicated to the subject of book trailers. You can either do a Google search for “book trailer wiki” or try the direct link which is
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_trailer
This has lots of external links to the best examples of book trailers and to newspaper and magazine articles about the growth of this new genre.
March 9, 2007 at 4:27 pm
I’m coming in on this REAL late, but since this post was posted in July, let me tell what’s happened since then. Book trailers have really taken off. I have one that I made at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOklaNgirZI …it’s my first attempt at making them, but I’ve had some nice responses about it. The way I see it, and you point this out above, is that we’ve got to attract the younger crowd. The younger crowd has been brought up on video games, whatever, and this is one way we can do it by providing a “visual.” These kids aren’t reading…what they ARE reading are things over the Internet, for example. I see good things coming from book trailers…I think they add that nice added visual touch as long as they are made well.
March 22, 2008 at 2:15 pm
What an interesting way to get people interested in reading! Book trailers are like movie trailers, but for books! You can find them all over the internet now, but here is a site that’s featuring them on YouTube. http://www.youtube.com/booktrailers